Back Page: Risk Assessment

New thinking and diagnostic tests may change how statins are marketed and prescribed.
Apr 30, 2006


Sunshine K. Mugrabi
Evidence that inflammation—not just blocked arteries—may be a leading cause of heart attack and stroke has triggered a race among genomic researchers to develop sophisticated new screening tools. It also could mean big changes in how risk is assessed.

For years, physicians have identified candidates for statin therapy primarily by a measure known as the Framingham risk score, which is based on a number of factors for both men and women: age, total cholesterol, LDL-and/or HDL-cholesterol levels, blood pressure, diabetes, and smoking. It doesn't take into account genetics or family history.

The problem, says Paul Ridker, MD, a physician at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, is that "half of all heart attacks and half of all strokes occur in people with normal cholesterol."

In 1997, Ridker and his colleagues found that high levels of an inflammatory marker known as high-sensitivity C-reactive protein (hsCRP) conferred a threefold risk of heart attack, compared with the 1.6-fold risk associated with elevated LDL-cholesterol. The conclusions were based on analysis of blood samples from 543 subjects in a large-scale, 13-year-long study.

The theory behind this: inflammatory proteins contribute to the development and eventual rupture of atherosclerotic plaques. In other words, they are markers for and contributors to heart disease.


New Risk Marker
Statins, in addition to acting on LDL-cholesterol, also reduce such inflammatory proteins by up to 30 percent. To test whether this aids in statins' effectiveness, Ridker is leading a 15,000-patient trial of Crestor using subjects with low cholesterol and high hsCRPs. The results, expected within three years, could cause a sea change in the way risk is assessed.

In light of such research, the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute released recommendations in December 2005 that the Framingham score be modified to include hsCRPs, along with novel biomarkers found through genomics, proteomics, and other cutting-edge methods.

Meanwhile, genomics firms worldwide are developing diagnostic tests and even drugs that build on this model of heart disease. In the coming months, Celera Diagnostics expects to roll out two genetic screening tests that its president, Kathy Ordoñez says will detect heart attack and stroke risk, and reveal which patients are most likely to benefit from statins.

Celera's first diagnostic tool, which Ordoñez says will likely be on the market within the next several months, offers a genetic risk assessment based on a small set of genes that are strongly associated with either increased risk of heart disease or protection against it. The cost to patients will be in the "hundreds of dollars per test," says a Celera spokesman, far cheaper than most genetic tests, but significantly more expensive than testing for LDL-cholesterol or hsCRPs.

Celera also is developing a test to determine whether a person responds well to statins. The new test also will debut within "months, not years," says Ordoñez The test focuses on several genetic markers. One, FCAR, was found to virtually eliminate a carrier's risk of a fatal heart attack when taking statins. The results also seem to show that FCAR carriers who do not take statins are in significantly more danger of fatal myocardial infarction than non-carriers.

Celera hardly has the field to itself, as many other genomics outfits—all of which have access to gene-sequencing tools and publicly available genetic data—are working on similar tests.

There also are some doubters, including Ridker, who says he doesn't believe that currently "there are any genetic risk factors worth measuring ... that will help predict the risk of heart attack or stroke and that would change a physician's practice."

In spite of this, genomic research of the link between heart disease and inflammation continues apace, and if successful, could shift the paradigm of detection and treatment of the Western world's number-one killer.

Sunshine K. Mugrabi is a freelance business and science writer. She can be reached at