Holy Surge of Enthusiasm! - Pharmaceutical Executive

ADVERTISEMENT

Holy Surge of Enthusiasm!


Pharmaceutical Executive


More of the Same

Nonetheless, obscured though they may be behind clouds of incense, or muffled by the outbreak of harmonious chorusing, some stubborn vestiges of the old industry dogma still lurk. At its most innocent, the pre-reformation doctrine emerges in messages such as the mild cautionary observation about the risks of excessive government cost-cutting: "The key is to avoid actions that have unintended consequences—too strong a focus on cost, rather than value, will undermine valuable innovation and therefore reduce patient benefit," EFPIA points out.

EFPIA claims that its members "have shown their commitment to work with governments to bridge funding gaps," and it invites any government "to talk to us about their needs"—because, it goes on, "EFPIA is committed to finding solutions that work short-term without having international knock-on effects and without hurting valuable innovation."

The tone sharpened perceptibly with warnings from Bergström that while major innovations are within the reach of industry, "there are significant challenges in delivering these to patients in an equitable way." And Witty upped the ante by pointing an accusing finger directly at politicians who are "not geared up" to thinking about effective ways of tackling healthcare problems, because they have "too short-term a horizon." Healthcare authorities lack the information systems that would allow them to understand what drives their overall costs and to identify accurately how to make real savings, he alleged, and the industry suffers from the "schizophrenia" that affects Europe's governments. Depicting his own industry in a way that conjured up images of a choirboy punished for stepping out of line, Witty remarked: "We have been taken behind the woodshed and given our treatment by the governments and everybody else."

Like a disappointed missionary who finds his message rejected by unsympathetic pagans, Witty inveighed against widespread resistance to arguments linked to overall healthcare expenditure: "People only care about what is in their silo. Nobody really believes they will have to worry about the consequences," he says. On top of that, he even attacked the very foundation of the institution he claimed to be seeking an understanding with: any progress in Europe is impeded, he suggested, by "the division of the member state and European competencies for this agenda." As a result, "we have duplication at several levels and an increase in bureaucratic barriers."

The overwhelming impression left by the EFPIA meeting is that although the industry says it has embraced a new vision, and claims to be a born-again believer in cooperation, little has changed in its inner soul. The same old determination appears to persist, to be devout only in a clear quid pro quo bargain where virtue is to be rewarded by guaranteed salvation. "We will make our medicines better, and it is up to member states to make provision for paying for them," says Witty. And he warned that "governments must not drive the pendulum too far in one direction—balance is their responsibility too." It is hard to resist the conclusion that the industry's odor of sanctity is tainted with a more earthy scent of the pursuit of wordly goods—that business model is still in place.

Reflector is Pharm Exec Europe's anonymous columnist, a commentator so close to the action in Europe that his identity must remain a secret


ADVERTISEMENT

blog comments powered by Disqus
UPCOMING CONFERENCES

Serialization Summit
San Diego, CA
Feb. 27-28, 2014



Advances in Aseptic Processing
San Diego, CA
Mar. 10-12, 2014



ClinTech 2014
Cambridge, MA
Mar. 11-13 2014


Investigator-Initiated and
Sponsored Research (IISR)

Philadelphia, PA
Mar. 19-20 2014

See All Conferences >>

Source: Pharmaceutical Executive,
Click here