Pharm Exec‘s 13th Industry Audit looks at how well a cross section of companies in big Pharma, mid-tier specialty and biotech are delivering against today’s hottest performance metric: shareholder value.
Pharm Exec‘s 13th Industry Audit looks at how well a cross section of companies in big Pharma, mid-tier specialty and biotech are delivering against today’s hottest performance metric: shareholder value. When we began the series back in September 2002, this kind of broad indicator-indeed the very concept of “value”-was often discounted by the investment community in favor of the narrow, predictable balance sheet measures linked to generally accepted accounting and financial principles. (Access the Audit here.)
Sentiment has changed, however, due to the failure of this approach to self-correct management hubris in taking unwarranted risks and papering over huge losses with shareholder money (remember Enron?) as well as increased government regulation and the subsequent rise of a stronger, more pluralist strain of shareholder activism. Hats off to our Audit partner, Professor Bill Trombetta of St. Joseph’s University’s Haub School of Business, for helping us pioneer this effort to insist that transparent indicators of value like brand loyalty, quality, and a customer-first orientation be placed at the center of the corporate decision chain. It certainly positioned the Pharm Exec editorial brand on the below side of history.
The Audit is a self-renewing venture, with new elements added each year to ensure it remains relevant to current events. We have added to 2014 a new metric-Return on Invested Capital (ROIC)-to identify more precisely how companies perform in generating a profit on its capital investments, minus the costs of that capital, whether it is in the form of debt or stock. The metric opens for discussion whether management should be expected to at least cover the cost of invested capital-for example, are stock buyback programs a “free” expenditure? Can these, in some cases, actually help erode shareholder value? With this metric, it is possible to see precisely how a company share price can rise at the same time that shareholder value goes down. Using all nine metrics, author Trombetta also delivers an interesting assessment on long-term prospects for two key mergers: the pending pact between AbbVie and Shire, where their performances on each metric complement each other impressively, creating a union leading from strength to strength; and the still unresolved hostile bid by Valeant for Allergan, which adds up to a more muddled “odd couple” pairing.
Finally, this year’s Audit takes advantage of its long, 13-year window to highlight the need to distinguish profit growth from increased revenues as the benchmark for evidencing true shareholder value. The table at right shows growth in profit versus growth in sales during the five years from 2009 to 2014, mediated by changes in Selling, General and Administration (SG&A) costs. The bottom line: the well managed company that delivers shareholder value will show profits growing faster than sales; when the reverse is the case, it indicates trouble in the form of pressures on price and gross margins as well as proliferating SG&A overhead. The star performers are our “stealth” players with the pedal to the metal against aging big Pharma-Novo Nordisk, Celgene, Allergan and, yes, Shire again-AbbVie must be smiling.
Fake Weight Loss Drugs: Growing Threat to Consumer Health
October 25th 2024In this episode of the Pharmaceutical Executive podcast, UpScriptHealth's Peter Ax, Founder and CEO, and George Jones, Chief Operations Officer, discuss the issue of counterfeit weight loss drugs, the potential health risks associated with them, increasing access to legitimate weight loss medications and more.
MDMA Therapy for Mental Health Conditions: Do the Benefits Outweigh the Risks?
October 25th 2024Despite a recent FDA Complete Response Letter issued to Lykos for midomafetamine capsules for the treatment of post-traumatic stress disorder, experts believe that the future is bright for psychedelic drugs that treat mental health conditions.
The Transformative Role of Medical Information in Customer Engagement
October 3rd 2024Stacey Fung, Head of Global Medical Information at Gilead Lifesciences, delves into the evolving role of Medical Information (MI) in the pharmaceutical industry. Covering key topics like patient engagement through omnichannel strategies, combating misinformation, and leveraging AI to enhance medical inquiries, the conversation with Stacey highlights MI's critical role in ensuring patient safety and supporting drug development. She also shares her professional journey and tidbits for early career professionals on professional development.
The Impact of Artificial Intelligence on the Creation of Medicines
October 24th 2024Najat Khan, chief R&D officer, chief commercial officer, Recursion, and Fred Hassan, director, Warburg Pincus, discuss how artificial intelligence can help reduce healthcare costs at the 20th Annual Young & Partners Pharmaceutical Executive Summit held at the Yale Club of New York.