OR WAIT 15 SECS
What many in our industry may overlook as they try to identify some new trend are the changes that move below our feet. And they have the potential to disrupt even the most thoughtful marketing plans, writes Al Topin.
It’s a new year with new forecasts, wise prognostications, and sage extrapolations informed by last year’s rear view mirror. They’re often insightful. Sometimes misguided. Always interesting.
What many in our industry may overlook as they try to identify some new trend, however, are the changes that move below our feet. Biopharma industry tectonic plates, if you will. These are forces so powerful that they will continue to shift our business not just this year, but into the foreseeable future. They’re not all new, but they’re not going away. And they have the potential to disrupt even the most thoughtful marketing plans. So ignore them at your peril as you plan for 2016.
1. The 10-year century
Change is faster today. Technology moves quickly. Thinking, experimenting, and iterating happen rapidly. And while this acceleration is bringing life-changing therapies to market faster than ever before, it’s also bringing more failed molecules and more me-too competitors. Leveraging exclusivity and setting competitive barriers become more difficult and the process becomes more intense.
How to succeed at this pace? You can either jump in and swim as fast as you can, or take the time to examine the market and focus your resources on the greatest potential for success. Each approach has its risks, so it’s a matter of which makes you less uncomfortable.
2. The ubiquitous 800-lb. gorilla
85% of pharmaceutical units sold in the US are generic. Pick virtually any specialty drug category, and sitting right in the middle is a well-known, generic 800-lb. gorilla that dominates the market. In Parkinson’s disease its levodopa, in gout its allopurinol, in the initial steps of treating rheumatoid arthritis its methotrexate. All are effective, cheap, taught in medical school, and on most formularies.
As science and technology allow us to move quicker, we face a pharmaceutical market filled with these gorillas. Many drugs introduced into gorilla-dominated markets hope for a reasonable share based on limited clinical claims, improved delivery, or the potential for better compliance. Head to head clinical trials with the market gorilla? That’s a risk decision that needs to be considered on multiple levels.
A new drug with any hope to take down a generic gorilla must offer an advantage so clear, so meaningful that it makes up for a price tag that makes payers instantly nauseous. The game today is outcomes and long-term cost reduction. And it is happening--with high-priced drugs that in some cases turn out to be cures. These are tomorrow’s blockbusters. So as they say in TV commercials “What’s in your Pipeline?”
3. High drama in the exam room
The key diagnostic questions have been asked, test results are in, and the critical moment is here. The physician informs the patient that he or she has a serious disease and begins to explain treatment options and next steps. A very personal, devastating version of “shock and awwww” begins. The patient is now forced to face the reality of a disease they probably had suspected and make treatment decisions they barely understand.
Moments of truth like this have been a part of medicine for centuries. So what’s different today? The opposing forces of a more complex dialogue versus a time-challenged physician. The physician, while sympathetic to the shock of hearing a difficult diagnosis, simply doesn’t have enough time to explain complicated therapies and answer questions before feeling pressured to move to the next patient. And given the emotional nature of these conversations, it’s unclear if the patient and their caregiver remember anything the doctor said beyond the diagnosis. Doctor-patient communication, so critical to therapy compliance, is compromised from the start.
What can be done to improve this moment of truth? More, better patient education and support. But perhaps more important, practitioner training designed to improve sensitivity and clarity when he or she is having that difficult conversation.
4 .The morphing of the pharma sales rep
According to Cegedim Strategic Data, the number of pharmacy industry sales reps declined 40% between 2006 and 2014. Not quite last man or woman standing, but dramatic none the less.
So in an era of no-see docs and dramatically-priced complex new drugs, what does the today’s remaining rep force look like? The “attack of clones” approach is over. No longer do four reps from the same company zero in on one high-writing physician. No longer will a rep be successful just by delivering the script they role-played at the sales meeting.
The successful rep’s new role has shifted from sales to support: Isolating barriers and patient problems then providing support/solutions to the physician, the practice and the office staff. The question for the manufacturer then becomes: What can we do to support our reps in this changing role?
5. The Hollywood pharm team
Have you ever thought about the surprising similarity between today’s Hollywood business model and that of pharmaceutical companies? What was once a studio system in which the directors, writers and stars were all kept in-house on contract and used for movie after movie is now a business of outsourcing. And what once were the in-house resources of pharmaceutical giants are now a pharm team of outsourced specialties. CROs, medical review, discovery and more are now orchestrated from best-of-class, proven partners that play well with others.
So the lesson learned here is that in an incredibly high-risk venture like launching a new movie or new drug, it’s best to spread the risk. How can you spread yours?
6. The Hollywood opening weekend
To keep going with the Hollywood analogy, let’s look at the concept of the opening weekend. Many Hollywood movies win or lose on first weekend’s receipts. A movie’s initial box office success may determine whether average movie go-ers decide to see the movie or not. A bad weekend means distributors cut their potential losses and pull the movie as soon as contracts allow. Expensive blockbusters turn into failures in a few short days, while cheaper independent films with low expectations become heroes by Monday.
Sound familiar? A new drug misses early, sky-high forecasts that management pushed higher. Uptake is slower than expected. All of the sudden, the brand is lucky to keep its initial budget for a full year and risks losing the attention of the sales force.
How can brand teams manage expectations when management, shareholders, and competitors expect a big box office weekend each launch? Thinking long term anyone?
7. The missing quarterback
With all the attention focused on patient centricity, one reality continues to be overlooked. In a world that’s shifted from treatment from primary care to specialties, where drugs are more complicated and expensive, and where illogical insurance coverage continues to frustrate patients, there’s a clear unmet need-for a quarterback.
Specialists focus on a specific body part or set of symptoms, handing the patient to the next specialist once their job is done. They may be the quarterback for one play or one set of downs, but not the entire game. Inpatients are managed by hospitalists, while outpatients often rely on many individual practitioners. And patient medical records, which should follow the patient, end up incomplete as a patient moves from one medical system or provider to another.
Some medical specialties have taken a broad overview and adjusted their approach to overall patient care. Neurological teams, diabetes specialists, cancer clinics and cardiology practices now focus on the whole patient and their treatment. Critical allied specialties, diagnostics and treatment services, even financial guidance are available within the same facility. The patient’s specialist becomes the quarterback directing the process. Often, when the disease and its treatment become complex, they also act as the patient’s primary care physician. Pharmaceutical manufacturers in these specialties have supported this model with in-depth patient and practice support programs. They should be the ones to emulate.
Seven tectonic plates moving at their own pace, sometimes one at a time, sometimes in combination. Pay attention to how they continue to shift the healthcare landscape, and adjust your plans accordingly.